Energy & Solar

Heat Pumps Explained: Costs, Savings, and What No One Tells You

Published Updated 7 min read
In this article
  1. 1.How Heat Pumps Work
  2. 2.Air Source vs. Ground Source
  3. 3.Real Operating Costs vs. Gas Furnace
  4. 4.Cold Climate Performance: Myths vs. Reality
  5. 5.IRA Incentives: What Is Left in 2026
  6. 6.When a Heat Pump Doesn't Make Sense
  7. 7.Questions to Ask Your Contractor
  8. 8.Bottom Line

Heat pumps are the most talked-about HVAC technology in America right now. The Inflation Reduction Act created federal tax credits and state-run rebates for them. Manufacturers advertise efficiency well above what any furnace can reach. Contractors are pushing them as replacements for gas furnaces. And homeowners are confused, understandably, about whether the hype matches reality.

Here's what heat pumps actually do, what drives their cost, and when they actually make sense.

How Heat Pumps Work

A heat pump doesn't generate heat. It moves it. In winter, it extracts heat from outdoor air (or the ground) and moves it inside. In summer, it reverses and works like an air conditioner, moving heat from inside to outside. This is the same basic technology as your refrigerator, scaled up.

The efficiency claim is real: because a heat pump moves heat rather than creating it by burning fuel, it can deliver more heating energy than the electricity it consumes. That is what manufacturers mean when they advertise efficiency figures no furnace can match. A gas furnace, by comparison, burns fuel and loses part of that energy as waste heat up the flue.

Air Source vs. Ground Source

Air source heat pumps (ASHP) are by far the most common type. They look like a standard AC condenser outside your house, and modern cold-climate models are built to keep heating in freezing weather. Ground source (geothermal) heat pumps use the earth's constant underground temperature (about 50F to 59F year-round) as their heat source, but require buried loop systems that drive up installation cost substantially.

Air-Source (ASHP)Ground-Source (GSHP)
Upfront costLowerHigher (buried loop required)
Depends on outdoor air temperatureYesNo
InstallationMinimal disruptionExcavation or drilling required
Lifespan and maintenanceStandardLonger life, less maintenance
Best forMost homes, moderate climatesNew construction, large properties
Qualitative comparison based on the U.S. Department of Energy geothermal heat pump overview

For most existing homes, air source is the practical choice. Ground source makes financial sense mainly when the installation cost can be amortized over a new build or major renovation, and when utility rates are high.

Real Operating Costs vs. Gas Furnace

The operating cost comparison depends entirely on your local electricity and gas prices, so run it with your own bills.

Illustrative example, using assumed numbers: assume a home needs 60 million BTU of heat per year, a gas furnace that is 96% efficient, and a heat pump that averages 3 units of heat per unit of electricity over the season. These are assumptions for the example, not measurements of any real home.

Gas Furnace (assumed 96% efficiency)

  • Gas needed: about 625 therms
  • At an assumed $1.20/therm: about $750/year
  • At an assumed $1.80/therm: about $1,125/year

Air Source Heat Pump (assumed seasonal average of 3.0)

  • Electricity needed: about 5,860 kWh
  • At an assumed $0.12/kWh: about $703/year
  • At an assumed $0.18/kWh: about $1,055/year
  • At an assumed $0.25/kWh: about $1,465/year

For reference, the US average residential electricity price was 18.31 cents per kWh in July 2026.

The takeaway: In this example, the heat pump costs about the same to run as the furnace when gas is expensive, and more when gas is cheap. Where electricity is expensive, a heat pump can cost more to operate than gas unless you're on a time-of-use plan or generating your own solar electricity.

Where heat pumps win decisively is the combined heating-and-cooling comparison. A heat pump replaces both your furnace AND your air conditioner. If you're replacing both systems anyway, the extra cost of a heat pump over a new furnace plus AC is often modest, and rebates, where available, can offset some of it.

Cold Climate Performance: Myths vs. Reality

The biggest objection to heat pumps is cold weather performance. Here's what's true and what isn't.

Myth: Heat Pumps Don't Work Below Freezing

Older heat pumps struggled in freezing weather, but cold-climate technology has improved significantly. The ENERGY STAR cold climate certification tests heat pumps down to 5F, and a certified unit keeps working below that temperature.

Reality: Efficiency Drops as Temperature Drops

As the outdoor temperature falls, a heat pump has to work harder to pull heat from the air. It still works, but it uses more electricity per unit of heat. This is why seasonal average efficiency matters more than the best-case rating, and why sizing the system correctly for your climate is critical.

Reality: You May Need Backup Heat

In climates with long stretches of very cold weather, contractors often recommend keeping a backup heat source, either electric resistance strips built into the heat pump air handler or an existing gas furnace kept as a dual-fuel system. ENERGY STAR notes that pairing a cold climate heat pump with a backup source heats the home most efficiently in the coldest conditions. The heat pump handles most heating hours; the backup covers the extremes.

IRA Incentives: What Is Left in 2026

The Inflation Reduction Act (IRA) created two separate incentive programs for heat pumps:

25C Tax Credit (Ended After 2025)

The 25C credit was 30% of qualified costs, with a limit of $2,000 per year for qualified heat pumps. It covered improvements made through December 31, 2025, so a heat pump installed in 2026 does not qualify.

Home Energy Rebates (State-Administered)

The IRA also funded two rebate programs that states run:

Rollout is state by state. As of 2026, the Department of Energy says the rebates are available in select states. Check your state energy office for current availability and eligibility. The 25C tax credit no longer applies to 2026 installations, so there is no federal tax credit to stack with these rebates.

When a Heat Pump Doesn't Make Sense

  • Your gas furnace is new and working well. If you recently installed a high-efficiency furnace, the operating cost savings from switching to a heat pump may take many years to cover the investment. Wait until your furnace reaches end of life.
  • Very high electricity rates with cheap gas. When electricity is expensive and gas is cheap, a heat pump can cost more to run than a modern gas furnace. Unless you're adding solar to reduce your electricity cost, the math may not work.
  • No existing ductwork and no budget for it. Installing new ductwork is a major added cost. Ductless mini-splits are an alternative, but they are priced per zone, so whole-house coverage adds up quickly.
  • You only need cooling. If you live in a warm climate where heating demand is minimal, a standard high-efficiency air conditioner costs less upfront and does the same cooling job. The heat pump premium only pays off when you use it for both heating and cooling.
  • Undersized electrical panel. Heat pumps need a dedicated high-amperage circuit. If your electrical panel is already at capacity, common in older homes, you may need a panel upgrade before the heat pump can be installed.

Questions to Ask Your Contractor

  1. What are the rated heating capacity and efficiency at low outdoor temperatures for the model you recommend?
  2. Is this an ENERGY STAR Cold Climate certified unit?
  3. Do I need backup heat, and if so, what type?
  4. What is the total installed cost, and what incentives am I eligible for?
  5. Will my electrical panel support this system, or do I need an upgrade?
  6. What is the estimated annual operating cost compared to my current system?

Bottom Line

Heat pumps are among the most efficient heating and cooling technologies available. They make the strongest financial case when you're replacing both a furnace and an air conditioner at end of life, when electricity rates are reasonable, and when your state offers a rebate. They're not a good investment when gas is cheap and your furnace is new, or when electricity rates are exceptionally high. Run the operating cost comparison with your actual local rates, not national averages. The right answer depends on your utility bills, not on marketing claims.

Frequently asked questions

How does a heat pump work?

A heat pump moves heat instead of generating it. In winter it pulls heat from outdoor air or the ground and brings it inside, and in summer it reverses and works like an air conditioner.

Do heat pumps work in cold weather?

Modern cold-climate heat pumps keep heating below freezing, but their efficiency drops as the outdoor temperature falls. In places with long stretches of very cold weather, contractors often recommend keeping a backup heat source.

Is a heat pump cheaper to run than a gas furnace?

It depends entirely on your local electricity and gas prices. Where gas is cheap and electricity is expensive, a heat pump can cost more to run, so run the comparison with your own utility bills.

Can I still get a federal tax credit for a heat pump?

No. The federal Energy Efficient Home Improvement Credit has ended, so a heat pump installed now does not qualify. State-run Home Energy Rebates may be available, so check your state energy office.

When is a heat pump not worth it?

When your gas furnace is new and working well, when electricity is very expensive and gas is cheap, when you have no ductwork and no budget for it, when you only need cooling, or when your electrical panel cannot support it without an upgrade.

Sources

Affiliate Disclosure: Some links in this article may be affiliate links. If you click through and make a purchase or sign up for a service, we may earn a commission at no additional cost to you. This does not influence our editorial recommendations. Read our full affiliate disclosure.

The Consumer Clarity Editorial Team

Our editorial team researches consumer topics independently, analyzing contracts, complaints, and industry data. We accept no sponsored placements and disclose all affiliate relationships. Every guide is reviewed for accuracy before publication.

Our Methodology