Home & Property

Hiring a Contractor: Red Flags, Contracts, and How to Protect Yourself

Published Updated 7 min read
In this article
  1. 1.Step 1: Verify the License
  2. 2.Step 2: Verify Insurance
  3. 3.Step 3: The Three-Bid Rule
  4. 4.Step 4: Payment Schedule
  5. 5.Step 5: Written Contract
  6. 6.Step 6: Lien Waivers
  7. 7.Step 7: Permits
  8. 8.Red Flags
  9. 9.If Something Goes Wrong
  10. 10.Bottom Line

Home improvement and repair is a huge market. The contracting industry ranges from highly skilled, licensed professionals to unlicensed operators who take deposits and disappear. The difference between a great renovation and a legal nightmare often comes down to what you do before the work starts. Here is how to hire right, structure the deal, and protect yourself when things go wrong.

Step 1: Verify the License

Licensing requirements vary by state and by trade. Most states require contractors to be licensed for work above a certain dollar threshold, and that threshold differs from state to state. Some trades — electrical, plumbing, HVAC — require specific trade licenses in nearly every state.

How to verify: Every state has an online contractor license lookup. Search "[your state] contractor license verification" and enter the contractor's name or license number. Verify that the license is active (not expired, suspended, or revoked), covers the type of work you need, and matches the name of the person or company you are hiring.

Why this matters: If an unlicensed contractor does bad work, you have limited legal recourse. Many states do not allow unlicensed contractors to sue for payment, which means they are more likely to cut corners since they are already operating outside the system. Insurance claims related to unlicensed work may also be denied.

Step 2: Verify Insurance

A contractor should carry two types of insurance at minimum:

  • General liability (GL) insurance: Covers property damage the contractor causes to your home during the work. Minimums vary, so ask what the policy limits are.
  • Workers' compensation (WC) insurance: Covers injuries to the contractor's employees on your property. If a worker falls off a ladder and the contractor does not have WC, the worker (or their attorney) may come after your homeowner's insurance.

How to verify: Ask the contractor for a Certificate of Insurance (COI) and call the insurance company directly to confirm the policy is active. Certificates can be forged or outdated. A legitimate contractor will have no problem providing this.

If they say they are a sole proprietor with no employees: They still need general liability. Workers' comp may not be required for sole proprietors in some states, but if they hire subcontractors, those subcontractors need their own WC coverage. Ask who will be doing the work.

Step 3: The Three-Bid Rule

Get written bids from at least three contractors for any significant project. This serves two purposes: it establishes a market price range for the work, and it reveals outliers. Illustrative example, using assumed numbers: if two bids come in at $12,000 and one comes in at $5,000, the low bid is not a bargain — it is a warning sign (cutting corners, missing scope items, or a bait-and-switch setup for change orders).

What a proper bid should include:

  • Detailed scope of work (not just "remodel bathroom")
  • Materials specified by brand and grade
  • Labor costs broken out separately
  • Timeline with start and estimated completion dates
  • Who pulls permits (should be the contractor, not you)
  • Payment schedule
  • Warranty terms

A verbal quote is not a bid. If a contractor will not put it in writing, move on.

Step 4: Structure the Payment Schedule

Payment structure is your primary leverage. Once you have paid in full, you have no leverage if the work is incomplete or defective. Here is the standard payment structure for most residential projects:

Step 5: Get a Written Contract

Every project should have a written contract, and many states require one by law. In California, for example, a written contract is required for all home improvement projects over $500. The contract should include:

  • Full legal name and license number of the contractor
  • Complete scope of work with specifications
  • Total price and payment schedule
  • Start date and estimated completion date
  • Change order process (how changes to the scope are priced and approved — always in writing)
  • Warranty terms for labor and materials, in writing (materials also carry manufacturer warranties)
  • Dispute resolution clause (mediation before litigation saves everyone money)
  • Cancellation/termination terms for both parties
  • Insurance and license information
  • Permit responsibilities

Never sign a contract with blanks. Every field should be filled in. "TBD" on price or scope is an invitation for a surprise.

Step 6: Lien Waivers

This is the protection most homeowners forget. If your contractor does not pay their subcontractors or material suppliers, those unpaid parties can place a mechanic's lien on your property — even though you paid the general contractor in full. In some states, you could be forced to pay twice.

How to protect yourself: Require lien waivers from the general contractor, every subcontractor, and every material supplier with each progress payment. A lien waiver is a signed document confirming that the party has been paid for the work completed to date and waives their right to file a lien for that amount.

There are two types: conditional (waiver is contingent on the check clearing) and unconditional (waiver is effective immediately). Conditional waivers with progress payments, and unconditional waivers with the final payment, is the standard approach.

Step 7: Permits

Any work that involves structural changes, electrical, plumbing, HVAC, or changes to the building envelope (windows, roofing, siding) typically requires a building permit. The contractor should pull the permit, not you. When a contractor asks you to pull the permit as a "homeowner-builder," they are usually trying to avoid scrutiny because they are unlicensed or their license has issues.

Unpermitted work creates problems when you sell the home. Buyers' inspectors and appraisers look for permits. Unpermitted additions or modifications can reduce your home's value, complicate the sale, or force you to tear out and redo the work.

Red Flags: When to Walk Away

  • Demands cash only and will not provide receipts
  • No written contract or refuses to detail the scope of work
  • Cannot provide license number or insurance certificate
  • Requests a large deposit or full payment upfront
  • Shows up unsolicited after a storm offering emergency repairs at a "discount" (storm chasers)
  • Pressures you to make a decision immediately ("I have another job lined up and can only hold this price today")
  • Has no physical office or business address
  • Multiple complaints on the BBB or state licensing board
  • Suggests skipping the permit to "save time and money"
  • Will not provide references from recent projects or let you see completed work

If Something Goes Wrong

  • Document everything: Photos, videos, written communications, receipts, and the contract. Do not rely on verbal conversations.
  • Put complaints in writing: Send a written notice (email with read receipt or certified mail) describing the deficiency and requesting a specific remedy within a specific timeframe.
  • File a complaint with your state contractor licensing board (for example, California's Contractors State License Board). This can trigger an investigation and may result in disciplinary action against the contractor.
  • Mediation before litigation: If your contract includes a mediation clause, use it. Mediation usually costs less and resolves disputes faster than court.
  • Small claims court: For disputes under your state's small claims limit, which varies by state, small claims court is fast, cheap, and does not require a lawyer.

Bottom Line

The vast majority of contractors are honest professionals. But the minority who are not can cause catastrophic financial damage. The protections outlined above — license verification, insurance confirmation, written contracts, structured payments, and lien waivers — cost you nothing except time. They are the difference between a successful project and a very expensive lesson. Do the homework before the hammer swings.

Frequently asked questions

How do I verify a contractor's license?

Use your state's online contractor license lookup and enter the contractor's name or license number. Confirm the license is active, covers the type of work you need, and matches the person or company you are hiring.

What insurance should a contractor have?

At minimum, general liability insurance for damage to your home and workers' compensation for injuries to their employees. Ask for a Certificate of Insurance and call the insurer directly to confirm the policy is active.

How much should I pay a contractor upfront?

Keep the deposit limited, tie progress payments to milestones, and hold the final payment until the work is done, the final inspection has passed, and you have lien waivers. Some states cap deposits by law, and a contractor who demands most of the price upfront is a reason to walk away.

What is a lien waiver and why do I need one?

If your contractor doesn't pay subcontractors or suppliers, they can place a mechanic's lien on your property even though you paid in full. A lien waiver is a signed document confirming the party has been paid, so collect them with each progress payment.

Should the contractor or the homeowner pull the building permit?

The contractor should pull the permit. A contractor who asks you to pull it as a homeowner-builder is usually trying to avoid scrutiny, and unpermitted work can cause problems when you sell the home.

Sources

Affiliate Disclosure: Some links in this article may be affiliate links. If you click through and make a purchase or sign up for a service, we may earn a commission at no additional cost to you. This does not influence our editorial recommendations. Read our full affiliate disclosure.

The Consumer Clarity Editorial Team

Our editorial team researches consumer topics independently, analyzing contracts, complaints, and industry data. We accept no sponsored placements and disclose all affiliate relationships. Every guide is reviewed for accuracy before publication.

Our Methodology