Debt Solutions in the UK: DMP, IVA and Bankruptcy Compared
In this article
Key Takeaways
- A debt management plan (DMP) is informal and flexible, but it is not a legal agreement and creditors do not have to accept it.
- An IVA is legally binding once enough creditors by value approve it, and any debt left unpaid at the end of the arrangement is written off.
- Bankruptcy usually ends after a relatively short period but has serious consequences for homeowners and certain professions.
- Free debt advice is available, and you do not need to pay for a debt management plan.
- The Breathing Space scheme gives you temporary legal protection from most creditor contact and enforcement action while you get debt advice.
If you are struggling with debt in the UK, there are several formal and informal routes to deal with it. The right solution depends on how much you owe, what assets you have, and whether your income is likely to recover. This guide covers the main options available in England and Wales. Scotland has its own equivalents, including the Debt Arrangement Scheme (DAS) and sequestration, which operate under different rules.
Before exploring any option, get free advice. Charities such as StepChange, Citizens Advice and National Debtline offer debt advice free of charge. Paying a company for a service you can get for free is costly: if you pay for a debt management plan, the provider takes part of your monthly payment to cover its fees, so less money goes to your creditors.
Debt Management Plans
A debt management plan (DMP) is an informal arrangement to repay your debts through one monthly payment to a DMP provider, which deals with your creditors for you. It isn't a legal agreement, and your creditors don't have to agree to the plan.
Debt charities such as StepChange offer DMPs, and you can get a DMP for free. The provider negotiates with your creditors, distributes your single monthly payment across your debts, and provides ongoing support.
The advantages of a DMP are flexibility and simplicity. You can change or cancel your DMP at any time, and anyone can get one whatever the amount of debt. The disadvantages are equally important: creditors are not legally obliged to accept the plan, they can stop accepting it or ask for more money, and they can still contact you about the debts. A DMP usually does not include priority debts such as rent or council tax, it can make it harder to borrow in the future, and how long it lasts depends on how much you owe and how much you can pay each month.
Avoid any company that charges fees for a DMP. Only use a DMP provider that is regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority, and remember that fees reduce the amount going to your creditors and extend the time it takes to clear your debts.
Individual Voluntary Arrangements
An individual voluntary arrangement (IVA) is a formal, legally binding agreement between you and your creditors, organised by an insolvency practitioner (IP). You repay what you can afford over a fixed period, usually over 5 years, and any debt left unpaid at the end is written off.
Not every creditor needs to agree: you need the agreement of creditors who cover at least 75% of the total amount you owe. Once the IVA is in place, your creditors cannot contact you about the debts included in it or take action against you to get their money back.
Monthly payments are based on the spare income you have after essential living costs. If you own your home, its value is taken into account: if your share of the available equity is more than £10,000, you make payments into the IVA for an extra year, so it lasts 6 years instead of 5.
An IVA affects your credit rating: you might find it difficult to get credit for 6 years after your IVA starts. If you fail to keep up payments, there's a risk you could be made bankrupt.
IVAs are expensive. Fees to set up and manage an IVA are around £5,000 on average. Some insolvency practitioners ask for a fee before setting up the IVA, while others take their fees from your monthly payments, so ask several practitioners for estimates and compare them before you commit.
Bankruptcy
Bankruptcy in England and Wales is a formal insolvency process that clears most of your debts. The bankruptcy period usually lasts 12 months, and it costs £680 to apply. You can pay the fee in instalments, but the whole amount must be paid before you submit your application.
You might be able to declare yourself bankrupt if you can't pay your debts and the amount you owe is more than the value of the things you own. A creditor can also apply to the court to make you bankrupt.
During bankruptcy, an official receiver or trustee deals with your assets, and your home and valuable possessions may be affected. If you're earning and have a small amount spare, you might be asked to make payments towards your bankruptcy debts. If you have an income payments agreement or order, you must keep paying it until it finishes, even after your bankruptcy has ended.
Bankruptcy has serious consequences beyond the financial. It is published on the Insolvency Register, and the register is updated within 3 months of your discharge, while the bankruptcy can stay on your credit reference file for 6 years from the date of your bankruptcy. If you're a solicitor, accountant, work in the financial sector or run your own business, check how bankruptcy could affect your job.
Not all debts are cleared by bankruptcy. You might still have to pay debts such as court fines, student loans and child maintenance arrears, and discharge from bankruptcy does not release you from debts incurred by fraud.
Debt Relief Orders
A debt relief order (DRO) is a simpler, lower-cost alternative to bankruptcy for people with relatively low levels of debt, low income, and few assets. You are generally eligible if you owe less than £50,000, have less than £75 a month spare income, have less than £2,000 worth of assets and do not own a vehicle worth £4,000 or more. You must also have lived or worked in England and Wales within the last 3 years and not have applied for a DRO within the last 6 years.
You do not need to pay for a DRO, and you apply through an approved debt adviser rather than on your own. While you have a DRO, you stop making payments towards your debts for 12 months, and after that you no longer need to pay them.
You cannot get a DRO if you own your home, and a DRO can be cancelled if your financial circumstances change. It is added to the Individual Insolvency Register, and it is removed from the register 3 months after the DRO ends but stays on your credit record for 6 years.
The Breathing Space Scheme
The Breathing Space scheme, formally known as the Debt Respite Scheme, applies in England and Wales, and the legislation came into force on 4 May 2021 and gives legal protection from creditor action for up to 60 days. The protections include pausing most enforcement action and contact from creditors and freezing most interest and charges on your debts.
To access Breathing Space, you must go through debt advice: a breathing space can only be started by a debt advice provider authorised by the Financial Conduct Authority or by a local authority. The debt adviser decides whether Breathing Space is appropriate and, if so, starts it through an electronic service run by the Insolvency Service. During the breathing space, you work with the debt adviser to find a suitable long-term solution.
There is also a Mental Health Crisis Breathing Space for people receiving mental health crisis treatment, and it lasts as long as the person's mental health crisis treatment, plus 30 days.
Breathing Space is not a debt solution in itself. It is a pause that gives you time and space to get proper advice without the pressure of creditor letters, phone calls, and enforcement threats. Most debts qualify, including credit cards, personal loans, overdrafts and utility bill arrears, while excluded debts include student loans and debts incurred from fraud. Tax and benefit debts are also likely to qualify, and council tax arrears can qualify depending on whether the instalments have fallen due.
Bottom Line
If your debts are manageable with reduced payments, a free DMP is the least disruptive option. If you need legal protection from creditors and can keep up payments for several years, an IVA writes off the balance and stops creditor action, but check the fees first. If your debts are unmanageable and you have few assets, bankruptcy or a DRO offers a fresh start. Use the Breathing Space scheme to buy time while you get advice. And never pay a company for help you can get free from a debt advice charity such as StepChange, Citizens Advice or National Debtline.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between a debt management plan and an IVA?
A debt management plan is an informal arrangement that creditors do not have to accept and that you can change or cancel at any time. An IVA is a formal, legally binding agreement arranged by an insolvency practitioner, and any debt left unpaid at the end is written off.
Should I pay a company to set up a debt management plan?
No. You can get a debt management plan for free from debt charities such as StepChange, and fees reduce the amount going to your creditors. Only use a provider regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority.
Which debts are not cleared by bankruptcy?
You might still have to pay debts such as court fines, student loans and child maintenance arrears, and bankruptcy does not release you from debts incurred by fraud. Bankruptcy can also affect your home and certain professions, so check its consequences first.
Who can get a debt relief order?
A debt relief order is a lower-cost alternative to bankruptcy for people with relatively low debts, little spare income and few assets. You cannot get one if you own your home, and you apply through an approved debt adviser rather than on your own.
How does the Breathing Space scheme work?
Breathing Space gives temporary legal protection that pauses most creditor contact and enforcement action and freezes most interest and charges while you get debt advice. It can only be started by an FCA-authorised debt advice provider or a local authority, and it is a pause rather than a debt solution in itself.
Sources
- Citizens Advice — Check your options for getting out of debt
citizensadvice.org.uk
- Citizens Advice — Check if an IVA is right for you
citizensadvice.org.uk
- Citizens Advice — Check if going bankrupt is right for you
citizensadvice.org.uk
Affiliate Disclosure: Some links in this article may be affiliate links. If you click through and make a purchase or sign up for a service, we may earn a commission at no additional cost to you. This does not influence our editorial recommendations. Read our full affiliate disclosure.
The Consumer Clarity Editorial Team
Our editorial team researches consumer topics independently, analyzing contracts, complaints, and industry data. We accept no sponsored placements and disclose all affiliate relationships. Every guide is reviewed for accuracy before publication.
Our Methodology